Which Digital Promotions Work For Pizza Restaurants?

In today’s competitive pizza market, smart digital marketing campaigns can be the secret ingredient that boosts sales and customer loyalty. From email blasts to text message offers and viral social media posts, pizzerias are finding that going digital delivers impressive returns. In fact, email marketing yields an average $42 return for every $1 spent, yet only about a quarter of businesses use it consistently. Text message promos see near-instant engagement with open rates around 98% (versus ~20% for emails) and a majority of redemptions occur within hours.

Meanwhile, social media and online ads can amplify a great deal into a viral sensation. This article breaks down which digital promotions actually work for pizza restaurants, backed by data from recent years. We’ll look at successful examples from both independent pizzerias and major chains in the U.S. and Canada, focusing on key metrics like ROI, customer engagement (opens, clicks), and offer redemption rates.

Email: Big ROI in the Inbox

Email may be one of the oldest digital channels, but it remains hugely effective for pizza promotions. Industry benchmarks show restaurant emails average about a 20% open rate and email marketing boasts one of the highest ROI of any channel. For example, one study noted $40–$42 in revenue for every $1 spent on email marketing. The key is to send targeted, value-packed emails that your subscribers want to open.

Example 1. Papa John’s “Interactive” Email Campaign: Papa John’s tested adding interactive content and personalized segmentation to their emails to build customer loyalty. The result was dramatic. Their emails achieved a 65% engagement rate, a 7.8% increase in conversion rate, and even a 30% drop in unsubscribe rates after making messages more interactive and relevant.

By tailoring content to customer interests and including fun interactive elements (like clickable menus or polls), Papa John’s significantly boosted customer interaction. This shows how engaging content can keep pizza fans reading and clicking, rather than deleting. It also underscores the importance of segmenting your audience – Papa John’s targeted different groups with different content based on their behavior, which helped drive those conversions.

Example 2. Volare’s Welcome Offer Newsletters: You don’t have to be a national chain to win with email. Volare Italian Restaurant, an independent pizzeria in San Antonio, revamped its email strategy and started capturing guest emails with a 15% off first visit signup offer. In just six months they collected 263 subscriber emails and began sending a monthly newsletter with food visuals.

The engagement blew past expectations – Volare saw an email open rate over 60% on these newsletters, triple the industry average. This sky-high open rate shows that when you build a small but interested list (and incentivize customers to join with a good offer), email can drive exceptional engagement even for a local pizzeria. The takeaway: consistency and value are key. Volare’s emails reminded customers about new specials and included a coupon, keeping their brand on customers’ minds and enticing them back in.

Why Email Works: Email marketing is essentially free advertising to your own customer base, which is why the ROI is so high. Successful campaigns often share a few traits: a strong subject line (to get that open), an enticing offer or useful info inside, and maybe a visual or call-to-action that drives the click or order. For example, Domino’s has found success emailing its loyalty members with “every two orders earns a free reward” reminders, keeping customers engaged in the program.

The data shows that regular email outreach can boost repeat orders – one survey suggests good restaurant email programs see 20–40% of customers reorder within a set period from email prompts. In short, a well-targeted email is an inexpensive way to drive online orders or store visits, whether you’re sending a VIP coupon to your top 100 customers or a newsletter to 10,000 subscribers. Don’t leave this high-ROI channel on the table.

SMS: Immediacy That Drives Action

If email is high-ROI, SMS marketing might be even more explosive for pizzerias. Text messages combine urgency and ubiquity – virtually all your customers have a phone in their pocket, and texts are read within minutes. Studies show 90% of texts are read in the first 3 minutes, and text offers spur customers to act fast. Critically, text subscribers tend to become more valuable customers.

In a 2021 benchmark report, pizza restaurants found that once a customer joins a text program, their visit frequency jumps ~44% and their spending increases ~23% over the next six months compared to non-subscribers. That translates to significant revenue from loyal repeat business. It’s no wonder retention is so high – 96% of people stayed subscribed to restaurant text programs after 90 days (far better than email lists). In short, SMS is a powerhouse for driving immediate sales and building frequency.

Example 1. Blaze Pizza’s 103x ROI Text Campaigns: Blaze Pizza, a fast-casual chain, provides a textbook example of SMS success. They launched an SMS marketing program in mid-2023 to complement their mobile and online ordering. First, Blaze ran a controlled test – one group of customers received texts about promotions, a control group did not. The result? The text group’s purchasing was 13% higher in that quarter than the control group. Proving the value, Blaze went all-in on SMS. In less than a year, they achieved a staggering 103x ROI on their text marketing (that’s not a typo – essentially $103 in revenue for every $1 spent).

Their campaign messages see an average 48% conversion rate (yes, nearly half of recipients take action), far above the industry average 13% for food & beverage texts. Even automated loyalty texts (like “you have a free reward”) see 170% conversion when counting repeat conversions. Blaze grew their subscriber list aggressively and now finds SMS indispensable for flash promotions (e.g. limited-time offers like a “Summer Send Off” deal or a new menu item announcement) because texts generate immediate traffic.

Example 2: Independent Franchise Text Blasts – 2300% ROI: SMS isn’t just for big budgets; smaller pizza chains are thriving with it too. One 14-location pizza franchise spanning three states rolled out a weekly text coupon campaign to drive traffic on slow days. Using a mix of in-store opt-in (advertising their text club at the counter) and digital sign-ups, they quickly built a sizeable list. Each week, they’d send a text like “Tuesday Special: Show this text for BOGO slices!”. These simple messages, often with a link to an online ordering deal, led to a massive 2300%+ ROI on their mobile marketing efforts.

In other words, for every $1 spent on the texting platform, they generated over $23 in sales – truly impressive. How did they do it? Aside from great offers, they used a “share with a friend” feature in the text, effectively turning customers into advocates and creating a viral loop. This viral sharing amplified reach beyond the original subscriber list. The campaign also incorporated an on-site loyalty kiosk (for walk-in customers to join the text club) to continuously grow their contacts. The outcome was more foot traffic on slow nights and higher average tickets from people redeeming group deals.

Why SMS Works: Text messaging combines personal reach with urgent call-to-action. People tend to respond to texts they opt into as if they’re from a friend. For pizza businesses, SMS is ideal for limited-time promotions (e.g. “Tonight only: get a free topping if you order by 8PM!”) or loyalty/reward updates. The engagement metrics are off the charts – as noted, ~98% open rates and very high coupon redemption.

The data clearly shows SMS drives frequency and incremental revenue. Mobivity (a restaurant SMS provider) reported that after joining a text program, guests visited 44% more often and were valued at an extra $12–$16 in revenue over six months. The only caution is to not over-text and to always provide value; otherwise that 96% retention after 90 days.

Get Started

Social Media: Going Viral and Engagement

For many customers, social media is the new storefront. A recent survey found 71% of 18–29 year-olds go to social media first for restaurant news and updates. Platforms like Instagram, Facebook, and TikTok let pizza shops show off drool-worthy photos, announce deals, and interact with fans in real time. The payoff can be huge: successful social campaigns can exponentially increase brand awareness for little cost, and even translate into real-world lines out the door. The caveat is that social ROI is sometimes measured in impressions and engagement rather than direct sales – but as the following examples show, great social content absolutely can drive revenue.

Example 1. Amici Pizza’s TikTok Fame (Independent): Perhaps the most heartwarming example comes from a single-location pizzeria, Amici Pizza in Mesa, Arizona. In 2024, the owners started posting candid TikTok videos sharing “a day in the life” of their family-run pizza shop – tossing dough, serving customers, making cannoli, etc. One video caught fire, then another. Before they knew it, Amici had gone massively viral on TikTok, amassing 155,000 followers and 10.9 million likes, with individual videos racking up between 1 and 7 million views each.

The impact on business was immediate and intense. Suddenly everyone wanted to try Amici’s pizza; they became a national sensation. Lines stretched out the door every day, to the point the overwhelmed owners actually had to pause their delivery service to keep up with in-store demand. Customers were driving in from out of state, saying they saw Amici on their TikTok feed. All this from organic, authentic social media storytelling – no big ad budgets. The takeaway for owners: consistency and personality on social media can build a fanbase. Show your team, your recipes, your unique vibe.

Example 2: Domino’s “Emergency Pizza” Campaign (Major Chain): It’s not just indie shops – big chains leverage social and digital buzz to score huge wins too. Domino’s has been especially innovative with digitally fueled promotions. One of their most successful recent campaigns was the “Emergency Pizza” promotion in 2023. The concept: every Domino’s loyalty program member got a credit for one free medium pizza – an “Emergency Pizza” – to use whenever they “needed” it. This clever promo wasn’t a traditional BOGO coupon or percentage-off; it was framed as a fun social talking point and a reward for loyalty.

The campaign absolutely blew up online. Domino’s tied it into pop culture, even promoting it with a tongue-in-cheek collaboration with Netflix’s Squid Game and Twitch gaming events. The result: the first wave of Emergency Pizza advertising generated 5 billion earned media impressions – the most in Domino’s history. In other words, news outlets, social media, and word-of-mouth spread the story far and wide, giving Domino’s free publicity on the scale of the Super Bowl. And it wasn’t just buzz – the promotion helped boost sign-ups for Domino’s revamped loyalty program.

Why Social Media Works: The common thread is that social media rewards originality and responsiveness. Pizza brands that engage in a fun, genuine way – whether it’s Wendy’s-style witty Twitter banter or mouthwatering Instagram food porn – often see payoffs in customer loyalty and attention. For pizzerias, some effective social tactics include: partnering with local food influencers for giveaways, using trending hashtags (like #NationalPizzaDay) with a special deal, running photo contests and leveraging Facebook or Instagram Live for events (e.g. live pizza-making demo). Given that 64% of marketers say social media is their most effective paid channel (with TikTok and Instagram leading the way), it’s clear that investing in social content is critical for reaching today’s pizza customer.

Influencer Marketing: Building Social Proof

As consumers increasingly turn to Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube for dining inspiration, influencer marketing has become one of the most effective digital promotion strategies for pizza restaurants. Influencers can amplify brand messaging in an authentic way that resonates with followers, especially among Gen Z and Millennial diners. According to a 2024 survey by Influencer Marketing Hub, 67% of 18–34-year-olds said they’ve tried a new restaurant based on influencer content, and food-related campaigns enjoy some of the highest engagement across platforms.

Example 1. Pizza Pizza (Canada) x TikTok Food Creators: In 2023, Pizza Pizza launched a “Creamy Garlic Dip” challenge on TikTok, partnering with Canadian creators who posted food hacks and ASMR dipping videos. The campaign generated over 12 million views and led to a 20% increase in garlic dip add-ons within the first month – proving the power of viral food content and short-form video.

Example 2. Brooklyn Pizza (Ontario) x Local Food Blogger: A single-location pizzeria in Hamilton partnered with a local food influencer with 40K followers on Instagram. The creator posted a behind-the-scenes video making their best-selling “East End Supreme” pizza. The post resulted in a 46% increase in Instagram followers for the restaurant and a weekend sales boost of 18%, driven by new first-time customers.

Why Influencer Marketing Works: Influencers bring credibility and visual storytelling that’s hard to replicate in traditional ads. Food content, in particular, performs exceptionally well on platforms like TikTok and Instagram, where visuals and personality drive engagement. Influencers can show off your menu, highlight limited-time offers, and drive direct orders using promo codes or affiliate links.

Paid Ads: From Clicks to Conversions

While organic social media can work wonders, paid digital advertising offers a more predictable way to drive pizza sales. This includes search ads (Google/Bing), display ads, promoted social posts, and any online campaign where you pay to get in front of customers. The advantage of digital ads is the ability to target specific audiences and to track results (clicks, conversions, ROI) with precision. For pizza restaurants, some of the most successful digital ad campaigns have been those that tie into promotions or deals. Here are a few data-backed examples:

Example 1. Domino’s “Carryout Tips” Campaign: Domino’s has repeatedly shown how marrying promotions with digital ordering can yield huge returns. A standout example was the Carryout Tips campaign first launched in early 2022. In this promo, Domino’s paid customers to pick up their own pizzas – giving a $3 coupon (“tip”) toward the next order if you placed an online carryout order now. It was a clever way to ease strain on delivery (during driver shortages) and reward carryout loyalty. The campaign was heavily advertised via digital channels (email, app notifications, online ads) as well as TV.

The results were phenomenal: during the first run (2022), customers claimed over 17 million of these $3 coupons, indicating massive participation. More importantly, Domino’s reported that the promotion significantly boosted sales – carryout orders surged, contributing to a 14.6% increase in carryout sales during that period. The buzz and goodwill from essentially “tipping” customers also led to over 2 billion earned media impressions for the campaign.

Example 2. New York Pizza’s Local Ad Targeting: It’s not only US companies – the concept of targeted digital ads works globally. New York Pizza, a major pizza chain in the Netherlands with 250+ stores, wanted to optimize their ads for each local market. Managing separate campaigns for hundreds of stores was daunting, so they used an automation platform to dynamically create and manage localized Google and Facebook ads. The impact of this tailored approach was a 16% increase in revenue across their system, attributed directly to better performing local ads, as well as a huge time savings in marketing management.

By ensuring each store was advertising the right deals to the right local audience (for example, a downtown store might advertise lunchtime slice specials to office workers, while a suburban store promotes family meal deals), New York Pizza saw more bang for their ad buck. This case underlines the importance of relevance in advertising – the more you can tailor the message to the audience, the better it will convert.

Why Digital Ads Work: The above examples make it clear that measurable, targeted advertising on digital platforms can directly translate to sales and positive ROI. Whether it’s Google search ads capturing the top Google Maps searches for “pizza” or social media ads leveraging the fact that people spend 2X more time texting and scrolling than reading email on their phones, the eyeballs are on digital. For pizza restaurants, a smart strategy is to integrate your promotions with your ad spend.

As a business decision-maker, you should expect to see metrics like Click-Through Rate (CTR) and Return on Ad Spend (ROAS) from your digital ads – aim for a CTR that’s above industry average (~1% for Facebook, for example) and a ROAS that’s comfortably above 1 (meaning you earn more than you spend – many pizza campaigns see 3–10× ROAS or higher). When you hit those numbers, you know your promotion is working.

Conclusion

In the digital age, pizza lovers are only a click or tap away. By studying these successful campaigns, pizza restaurant managers and owners can see what’s possible: triple-digit ROI from a text blast, millions of impressions from a creative promo, double-digit sales growth from savvy ads, and viral fame from authentic social media posts. The common recipe is a mix of creativity, data-driven strategy, and understanding your customer.

Whether you run a single neighborhood pizzeria or a national franchise, embracing digital promotions – and learning from the best – can ultimately drive more people to crave your pizza. And as the numbers show, that translates into real dough (pun intended) for your business!

Which Digital Promotions Work For Pizza Restaurants?

Email: Big ROI in the Inbox

SMS: Immediacy That Drives Action

Social Media: Going Viral and Engagement

Influencer Marketing: Building Social Proof

Paid Ads: From Clicks to Conversions

Conclusion

Table of Contents

sales@gosnappy.io

support@gosnappy.io

1-855-818-0058